lessons from urban planning in COVID


Blogs are a double-edged sword. These on the web essays can be created by anybody with access to a laptop and the internet. The writers could be nicely-informed authorities with beneficial insights to share, or formal govt organizations. Some bloggers are exceptional tutorial authors who have printed their work in available databases, like Scopus, Net of Science and Google Scholar. Others may possibly be improperly knowledgeable persons basically sharing a biased impression.

Though visitors could possibly be able to remark on a blog site, the materials does not have the status of peer-reviewed tutorial investigate. Checks for high-quality and reliability are not designed into site publishing as they are in tutorial journals. Earlier exploration has reviewed the purpose of blogging communities as reference sources in scientific manuscripts. The University of Cambridge has warned its researchers not to rely on them.

But some weblogs still have attraction as sources of info and thoughts for researchers simply because they frequently deal with new circumstances that have not nevertheless been included in the traditional academic literature.

The emergence of COVID was a perfect illustration of a new and fast-transforming condition like this. Large quantities of information and facts had been becoming out there on line — some of it in blogs that had been dependable and handy to the community and to academics, some not.

Researchers and students have to have to know how to stability their info resources.

Tiny is acknowledged about how to detect trusted blog material in our subject of study, city preparing. We decided to discover this, setting up by seeking at which varieties of weblogs had been presently becoming cited by academics, and what requirements they have been making use of to guideline their choice of weblogs.

We discovered the blogs cited in tutorial publications ended up mostly published by governmental and non-governmental organisations. We analysed the methods in which these weblogs had motivated the public dialogue in excess of COVID, and shown that they were being launched on unique concepts that had not but been through peer assessment.

We also arrived up with 3 strategies that teachers can use for citing blogs in their exploration.

Citing weblogs about COVID-19

A good deal of lecturers and scientists of city arranging and design and style turned to weblogs throughout the coronavirus outbreak for facts. We performed a scoping study in 2020, analysing 31 samples from 4 kinds of blogging sources cited in 10 publications posted in 7 journals. We appeared at social sciences journals printed in 2020 and searched for weblogs that have been used as references in this kind of content about COVID-19.

We found that in the year 2020, academics and scientists in city planning and design employed weblogs generated by four varieties of publishers: authorities organizations, nongovernmental organisations, personal groups, and persons.

Furthermore, we located that teachers and researchers cited blogs for a few motives:

  • collecting quantitative data resulting from statistical investigation

  • shedding mild on qualitative information relevant to social solutions like social distancing and lockdown

  • confronting the troubles of pandemics by way of the concepts of urban planning.

Conditions for citing blogs

This evaluation was aspect of a wider review of the use of blogs by teachers. Based on this work, we have 3 recommendations for locating blogs that publish scientific results on important subjects like COVID-19 and can be cited in scholarly content articles.

  1. It is possible for teachers and scientists in urban planning and style and design to cite weblogs in their scholarly works. This is carried out by deciding on posts that supply relevant examination, effects and results completed by federal government businesses and nongovernmental organisations.

  2. For blogs written by men and women or personal teams this kind of as Brookings and
    CityLab, it crucial to retain observe of bloggers in scientific databases, like the Website of Science, Scopus or Google Scholar. Numerous metrics can support to realize bloggers’ standing, such as the variety of citations, h-index, and normalised citation influence.

  3. Citing blogs can be based on the number of sights or assessments, which can show the likelihood of an open up-ended debate about the publish. Having said that, it is critical to try to remember that although blog site sights can appear vital, they are not automatically a trusted metric to cite blogs. Weblog views replicate the significance of the matter rather than the dependability of the data furnished in the site.

By adhering to these guidelines, teachers and researchers can use weblogs as trusted sources of data. They can be cited in scholarly publications for rising concerns these types of as COVID-19 in its early levels. These recommendations can tutorial teachers and researchers when they tackle subject areas however under research or not coated in scientific scientific tests.


Source hyperlink